The Integral Approach
As mentioned, the first approach entails the second: the integral approach. A complex piece
of print, the kind often seen, poses not just a problem of typesize or line width. On the
contrary; in a single design, the solutions to many problems have to be found
‘simultaneously’, because typesize and other typographical aspects often interact to create a
unique problem. This means that, in research, each aspect of typography should not be
studied separately. Perhaps researchers need to consider that the ultimate aim of typographic
design is not to optimize the usability of every single typographic aspect. This is simply
impossible, because all aspects need to be balanced and optimizing some will leave a choice
of non-optimal options for the other aspects. Rather than aiming to optimize all aspects of
typography individually, designers look to optimize the combination of aspects. There is no
harm in testing a design by considering the total effect of all aspects at once; it just means
that the unique effect of one aspect can not be seperated from the effect of all other aspects.
However, this is not to say that studying some aspects seperately is useless and out of the
question. It was suggested earlier, for example, that survey research could be used to
determine readers’ aesthetic preference of type. This could easily be studied separately and
produce useful results.